Guaranteed to teach you things you never knew.
Shutterfly Metal Ornament Review: Pros, Cons and Our Verdict

Shutterfly Metal Ornament Review: The Short Answer
• Verdict: The Shutterfly metal ornament is a durable, two-sided photo ornament at a fair price, rated 4.3/5 by our ornament rating criteria.
• Price: $24.99 (one-time, includes ornament, red ribbon and storage pouch), in any of four shapes. Shipping is calculated in the cart.
• Best for: Families who want a light, sturdy metal photo ornament with a photo and a short message on both sides.
• Biggest strength: Coated aluminum printed in full color on both sides, in a round, square, rectangle bracket or gift tag shape.
• Biggest drawback: It holds one photo and some text, with no way to add a voice, a video or the story behind the picture.
• Trustpilot: 4.0/5 from 30,219 reviews of Shutterfly as a whole (as of November 2026).
A Shutterfly metal ornament review has to answer two questions most product pages skip: what $24.99 really buys, and whether the ornament reaches the tree before December 25. Many families order several at once, for grandparents, siblings and their own tree.
This review covers how the ornament works, the full cost of one and of four, Shutterfly's 2026 holiday shipping cutoffs, what Trustpilot reviewers say, who it suits, and the alternatives worth a look, including photo ornaments that also play recorded family stories.
What Is the Shutterfly Metal Ornament?
The Shutterfly Upload Your Own Design Metal Ornament is a coated aluminum Christmas ornament that prints one of your photos, plus text, in full color on both sides. The ornament is made by Shutterfly, which also sells photo books, cards, prints and other photo gifts.
It's a one-time purchase in four shapes, with a red ribbon and a soft protective pouch. Shutterfly says it's imported and personalized in the USA.
How Does the Shutterfly Metal Ornament Work?
Ordering a Shutterfly metal ornament takes five steps, all on Shutterfly's website:
- Pick a shape: round, square, rectangle bracket or gift tag.
- Upload one photo from your device.
- Personalize both sides with your photo and text, such as a family name, the year or a short note.
- Choose a shipping tier at checkout. The cart shows the delivery date for your ZIP code.
- Hang it with the included red ribbon. Store it in the pouch it ships in.
Shutterfly's shipping page lists production and delivery together, from 1-2 business days (Super Rush) to 6-10 business days (Basic Economy). Shutterfly ships within the US and also lists holiday cutoffs for Canada and international orders.
How Much Does a Shutterfly Metal Ornament Cost?
A Shutterfly metal ornament costs $24.99 at its regular price, as listed on Shutterfly's product page on November 5, 2026. The price is the same for all four shapes.
What one finished Shutterfly ornament really costs
One ornament costs $24.99 before shipping. Shutterfly doesn't publish a flat shipping fee: the cart calculates it from your ZIP code and the tier you choose. Each extra ornament is another $24.99, and every copy can carry a different photo.
Four ornaments (one to keep, three to give) on regular prices:
Shutterfly often runs sitewide sales (a $9.99 sale price was showing on November 13, 2026), so you may pay less. This review uses regular prices only.
Refunds, returns and the Shutterfly guarantee
Shutterfly backs orders with a "100% Happiness Guarantee": if something isn't right, Customer Care works with you to fix it. Its return policy adds limits. If a return or refund request isn't due to a Shutterfly error, or comes more than 60 days after the order date, Shutterfly may issue store credit instead of a refund or apply a 50% return fee. Shutterfly doesn't refund return shipping.
When Do You Need to Order a Shutterfly Ornament for Christmas?
To have a Shutterfly ornament for the holidays, order by December 16, 2026 with Economy shipping, or as late as December 21 with Super Rush. These are the 2026 cutoffs Shutterfly posted on its shipping page on November 5, 2026, and Shutterfly notes that some items have earlier cutoff dates, so the cart is the final word.
For comparison, the Remento Ornament's order-by date is December 14, 2026 for delivery by December 24, and it ships within the US. Shutterfly gives last-minute shoppers more room, as long as they pay for a faster tier.
What Are the Shutterfly Metal Ornament's Key Features?
Coated aluminum, light enough for any branch
The ornament is made of coated aluminum. Shutterfly describes it as durable, high-quality and "lightweight enough for any branch."
Four shapes and sizes
Shutterfly offers four shapes at the same $24.99 price:
- Round: 3.25" in diameter
- Square: 3.125" x 3.125"
- Rectangle bracket: 3" x 4"
- Gift tag: 3" x 5"
The gift tag is the largest print area, which helps if you want room for a longer note.
Photos and text on both sides
Both sides can be personalized with photos and text. The product page lists it as a one-photo design, so plan on one favorite picture plus a name, a year or a few words.
Print only, with no voice or video
The ornament can show a photo and text, but it can't hold a recording of anyone telling the story behind the picture. It ships in a soft pouch with a red ribbon, not a gift box.
Shutterfly Metal Ornament Review Score: 4.3/5
The Shutterfly metal ornament scores 4.3 out of 5 on our four ornament rating criteria. It's strong on build, price and ordering, and lower on storytelling because it holds only a photo and text.
Every ornament is scored on the same four criteria from facts on each brand's own website. The full method is in our comparison of the best photo ornaments.
What Do Customers Say About Shutterfly?
Shutterfly has a 4.0 out of 5 rating on Trustpilot from 30,219 reviews, as of November 13, 2026. That rating covers the whole brand (photo books, cards, prints and gifts), not ornaments alone. Here's what reviewers who mention ornaments say:
"Yearly I create over 75 photo ornaments and 2 photo books for family, friends and coworkers and they are loved and treasured by the recipients." (Phyllis B., 5 stars, November 2026, Trustpilot)
"I have also ordered portraits, ornaments and framed pictures which turn out great every time!" (Sara, 5 stars, October 2026, Trustpilot)
"The ornament i ordered was not cropped properly. The hole where the ribbon was placed went through the eye of the person's face that was on the ornament." (Kathy M., 3 stars, November 2025, Trustpilot)
These reviews show loyal customers reordering ornaments year after year, and one complaint about a photo placed too close to the ribbon hole. Check the preview before you check out.
Shutterfly Metal Ornament Pros and Cons
Pros
- Coated aluminum is durable and light enough for any branch
- Four shapes, from a 3.25" round to a 3" x 5" gift tag, all at $24.99
- Photos and text on both sides
- Shipping tiers as fast as 1-2 business days, with posted holiday cutoffs
- Each ornament can carry a different photo when you order several
Cons
- One photo per ornament
- No voice, video or QR code, so the story behind the photo isn't captured
- Ships in a pouch, not a gift box
- Shipping cost and the exact arrival date appear only in the cart
- Returns that aren't due to a Shutterfly error may get store credit or a 50% fee
Who Should (and Shouldn't) Buy a Shutterfly Metal Ornament?
The Shutterfly metal ornament is a good fit if...
- You want a sturdy, lightweight photo ornament that's easy to hang.
- You're ordering several ornaments with a different photo on each.
- You're shopping late and willing to pay for Rush or Super Rush shipping.
Consider something else if...
- You want the ornament to hold the story behind the photo, not just the photo.
- More than one person wants to be part of the gift, with their own words.
- You'd like the ornament to arrive ready to give, in a box.
Shutterfly Metal Ornament vs Remento Ornament
The biggest difference is what each ornament holds: Shutterfly prints a photo and text on metal, while Remento prints a photo on ceramic and puts recorded family stories behind a QR code on the back.
Choose the Shutterfly metal ornament if...
- You want metal rather than ceramic, or a larger shape like the gift tag.
- You need it fast, or you're shipping to Canada or abroad.
- Each ornament in your order needs its own photo.
Choose the Remento Ornament if...
- You want to hear the people in the photo tell what happened that day.
- Siblings, cousins or grandparents want to add their own memories of the same moment.
Where the Remento Ornament falls short: it ships within the US only, and it's ceramic rather than metal.
Start with a photo, then record the story behind it.
Shutterfly Metal Ornament Alternatives
If the Shutterfly metal ornament isn't quite right, these photo ornaments, starting with Remento's own, were scored on the same rating criteria in our side-by-side ornament roundup:
- Remento Ornament: best overall photo ornament, and the only one here that plays the voices behind the photo. $29.99 (one-time). Rated 4.8/5.
- Mpix Custom Ornament: best for fast shipping. $19.99 (one-time). Rated 4.5/5.
- Personalization Mall Porcelain Heart Family Photo Ornament: best heart-shaped photo ornament. $34.99 (one-time). Rated 4.1/5.
- Personal Creations Picture-Perfect Photo Round Ornament: best rustic wood photo ornament. $19.99 (one-time). Rated 4.0/5.
- Minted Custom Ceramic Photo Ornament: best artist-designed photo ornament. $55.00 (one-time). Rated 3.8/5.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Shutterfly ornaments good quality?
Yes, by Shutterfly's own description. The metal ornament is made of durable, high-quality coated aluminum that shows photos in crisp, vibrant color, and it's imported and personalized in the USA. Shutterfly holds a 4.0 rating from 30,219 Trustpilot reviews, though that covers the whole brand rather than ornaments alone.
What do Shutterfly metal ornament reviews say?
Shutterfly's Trustpilot rating is 4.0 out of 5 from 30,219 reviews as of November 13, 2026. Reviewers who mention ornaments include repeat buyers who make dozens every year. One critical review describes a photo cropped so the ribbon hole went through a face, so check the preview before ordering.
How much is a Shutterfly metal ornament?
$24.99. That's the regular price on Shutterfly's product page for the Upload Your Own Design Metal Ornament in any of its four shapes, as of November 5, 2026. Shutterfly often runs sitewide promo codes that lower it, and shipping is calculated in the cart.
Can you add text to a Shutterfly ornament?
Yes. The Shutterfly metal ornament supports photos and text on both sides, so you can add a family name, the year or a short note. The product page lists it as a one-photo design.
How long does a Shutterfly ornament take to arrive?
Between 1 and 10 business days, depending on the shipping tier. Shutterfly lists production and delivery at 6-10 business days for Basic Economy, 5-7 for Standard, 4-5 for Expedited, 3-4 for Rush and 1-2 for Super Rush. For the 2026 holidays, its US order-by dates run from December 16 (Economy) to December 21 (Super Rush).
Can you return a Shutterfly ornament?
Yes, through Shutterfly Customer Care. Under its 100% Happiness Guarantee, Shutterfly works to make an unsatisfactory order right. If the request isn't due to a Shutterfly error, or comes more than 60 days after the order, Shutterfly may give store credit instead of a refund or apply a 50% return fee, and it doesn't refund return shipping.
Does Shutterfly do Christmas ornaments?
Yes. Besides the metal ornament reviewed here, Shutterfly's product page links to upload-your-own-design ornaments in frosted glass, cube, jeweled, keepsake and luxe frame styles, and Shutterfly also sells a natural slate ornament.
Final Verdict: Is the Shutterfly Metal Ornament Worth It?
Yes, if a photo and a short message are what you want on the tree. The Shutterfly metal ornament earns 4.3/5 for durable two-sided aluminum, four shapes and a fair $24.99 regular price, and its fast shipping tiers suit late December orders. The cost fact to know: shipping is set in the cart, so the total depends on your ZIP code and speed. It can show a moment, but it can't hold anyone's voice describing it. If you want the people in the photo to tell the story in their own words, the Remento Ornament is the better pick.
Hear the story behind the photo. The Remento Ornament is $29.99 (one-time, includes ornament and recordings behind the QR code), with unlimited recordings from family and friends.
See how the Remento Ornament works
Related Reading
- All Remento personalized photo ornaments
- Six photo ornaments compared and scored
- How the Remento Ornament plays your family's voices

Their stories, forever at your fingertips
Remento’s life story books turn a parent or grandparent’s memories of the past into a keepsake book for the future - no writing required.
Capture priceless family memories today
Join the thousands of families using Remento to preserve family history, all without writing a word.
.avif)
