Early Black Friday Sale: Save up to $50
Shop now!
November 2026

Mpix vs Shutterfly Ornaments: 5 Key Differences Before You Buy

by

Mpix vs Shutterfly Ornaments: The Short Answer

• Bottom line: In the Mpix vs Shutterfly ornament matchup, both make a full-color metal photo ornament printed on both sides. Mpix costs less and offers more shapes; Shutterfly offers more shipping speeds and ships beyond the U.S.

• Choose Mpix if you want two photos on one ornament, eight shape options or a lower price on several copies of the same design.

• Choose Shutterfly if you want a larger ornament (up to 3x5 in.), a protective pouch included, Super Rush delivery or shipping to Canada or abroad.

• Price (regular, one-time): Mpix Custom Ornament $19.99 (one ornament); Shutterfly Upload Your Own Design Metal Ornament $24.99 (one ornament).

• Ratings: Mpix scores 4.5/5 and Shutterfly 4.3/5 by our ornament rating criteria. On Trustpilot (brand-wide), Mpix is rated 3.7 and Shutterfly 4.0.

Mpix and Shutterfly both turn a favorite photo into a metal Christmas ornament, and at a glance they look almost identical. The differences show up when you order more than one, pick a shape or count the days until it needs to be on the tree. This guide compares the Mpix Custom Ornament and the Shutterfly Upload Your Own Design Metal Ornament on price, photos and design, size, shipping and what comes in the box. It covers the two brands' metal photo ornaments only, not their prints or photo books.

Mpix vs Shutterfly Ornaments at a Glance

Mpix Custom Ornament Shutterfly Metal Ornament
Price (regular, one ornament) $19.99 $24.99
Price for 2+ of the same design $17.50 each $24.99 each
Material 1/16 in. aluminum, glossy finish Coated aluminum
Printing Double-sided Two-sided (photos and text)
Photos Up to 2 1
Shapes 8 4
Largest size Gift Tag, 2.85x4.33 in. Gift Tag, 3x5 in.
In the box Red ribbon Red ribbon and soft protective pouch
Gift packaging Boutique packaging, $10.00 add-on Not stated
Production and shipping 1-2 business days in lab, then shipping 1-10 business days total, by shipping tier
Ships to United States U.S., Canada and international
Voice or video No No
Guarantee 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed 100% Happiness Guarantee (conditions apply)
Rating (our ornament criteria) 4.5/5 4.3/5
Trustpilot rating 3.7 (140 reviews) 4.0 (30,219 reviews)

How Does Each Ornament Work?

Both brands use the same basic flow: pick a shape, add your photo, personalize, then choose shipping. The difference is in how much design help you get.

How the Mpix Custom Ornament works

  1. Choose a trim (shape), such as Circle, Christmas Ball, Snowflake or Gift Tag.
  2. Pick one of Mpix's artist-designed holiday designs and add up to two photos.
  3. Edit the wording and colors, then preview the front and back. Mpix asks you to sign in to design.
  4. Mpix prints on 1/16 in. aluminum and ships the order within 1-2 business days in the lab, plus shipping.

How the Shutterfly Metal Ornament works

  1. Choose one of four shapes: Rectangle Bracket, Round, Square or Gift Tag.
  2. Upload one photo, or upload your own finished design.
  3. Add text on either side, such as a family name, the year or a short note.
  4. Pick a shipping tier at checkout; the cart shows the exact arrival date for your ZIP code.

Mpix vs Shutterfly Head-to-Head

Mpix wins two of the four criteria in our ornament rating criteria, and the other two are ties. Here is how each one breaks down.

Memory and storytelling

Winner: Mpix (4/5 vs 3.5/5). Mpix lets you place up to two photos on its double-sided ornament, so the front and back can show two different moments, such as a newborn photo and a first-birthday photo. Shutterfly's metal ornament is designed for one photo, with text on both sides for a name, a year or a note. Neither ornament stores voice, video or any recording.

Ornament quality

Winner: Tie (4.5/5 each). Both are full-color prints on aluminum. Mpix uses a 1/16 in. aluminum sheet with a glossy finish and says its ornaments are handmade in the USA. Shutterfly describes its ornament as durable, coated aluminum that is light enough for any branch, imported and personalized in the USA. Mpix warns that very small faces (1/4 in. or less on the final ornament) may print soft.

Value

Winner: Mpix (5/5 vs 4.5/5). One Mpix ornament is $19.99, $5.00 less than Shutterfly's $24.99. The gap widens with quantity: Mpix drops to $17.50 each when you order two or more with the same trim and design, while Shutterfly's listed price stays at $24.99 each. Shutterfly does include a protective pouch at no extra cost.

Ease of ordering and gifting

Winner: Tie (4.5/5 each). Mpix is quick to produce, with 1-2 business days in the lab, and offers boutique gift packaging for $10.00 per order. Shutterfly offers five shipping speeds, ships to Canada and other countries, and guarantees the arrival date shown in the cart on its Standard and faster tiers. Mpix requires an account to design; Shutterfly's shipping cost appears only at checkout.

How Much Do Mpix and Shutterfly Ornaments Cost?

Mpix is cheaper at every quantity: $19.99 for one ornament versus $24.99 at Shutterfly, both regular one-time prices. Prices on this page are each brand's regular price for one ornament, as listed on its own website on November 11, 2026. Sales and promo codes are excluded.

Cost scenario Mpix Shutterfly
One ornament $19.99 $24.99
Each extra copy (same design) $17.50 each when ordering 2+ $24.99
Four identical ornaments $70.00 $99.96
Shipping Standard $9.99 (free on orders over $45); Expedited $19.99 Shown in cart; not published on the site
Gift packaging $10.00 boutique packaging (one box per order) Pouch included; gift box not stated

The four-ornament scenario. Many people order one photo for several relatives, such as a set for each grandparent or sibling. On regular prices, four identical Mpix ornaments cost $70.00, and that total qualifies for Mpix's free Standard shipping on orders over $45. Four Shutterfly metal ornaments cost $99.96 before shipping, which Shutterfly calculates in the cart. That's a $29.96 difference before Shutterfly's shipping.

Dated note (November 11, 2026): Shutterfly was advertising a sitewide sale and free shipping on orders of $99+ with a code. Promotions change often, so check both sites before you order.

What Do Customers Say About Mpix and Shutterfly?

Shutterfly holds the higher Trustpilot rating and a far larger review base. Both ratings cover each brand's whole business, not only ornaments.

Mpix: 3.7 on Trustpilot from 140 reviews (November 11, 2026).

"Outstanding quality, fast and excellent customer service. My new go-to for great quality pictures and art work."
(Eleni L., 5 stars, November 2026, Trustpilot)
"First, the designer was suggesting a missing design element compared to their product photo."
(Caroline B., 2 stars, February 2023, Trustpilot, reviewing an ornament for a first Christmas married)

Shutterfly: 4.0 on Trustpilot from 30,219 reviews (November 13, 2026).

"I ordered Photo ornaments for my grandchildren, and they turned out beautifully. Very pleased with the quality and sharpness of the photo on the ornament."
(Diane L., 5 stars, April 2026, Trustpilot)
"The ornament i ordered was not cropped properly. The hole where the ribbon was placed went through the eye of the person's face that was on the ornament."
(Kathy M., 3 stars, December 2025, Trustpilot)

Pros and Cons

Mpix pros

  • Lower price: $19.99, or $17.50 each for 2+ of the same design
  • Up to two photos with double-sided printing
  • Eight shapes, including Snowflake and Christmas Ball
  • 1-2 business days in the lab before shipping
  • Free Standard shipping on orders over $45

Mpix cons

  • Lower Trustpilot rating (3.7) from a small review base
  • Account required to design
  • Gift packaging costs $10.00 extra
  • Ships within the United States only
  • No voice or video

Shutterfly pros

  • Larger sizes, up to a 3x5 in. Gift Tag
  • Red ribbon and soft protective pouch included
  • Five shipping speeds, down to 1-2 business days with Super Rush
  • Ships to Canada and international addresses
  • 4.0 Trustpilot rating from more than 30,000 reviews

Shutterfly cons

  • $5.00 more per ornament at regular price, with no listed quantity price
  • One photo per ornament
  • Shipping cost appears only in the cart
  • Store credit or a 50% return fee may apply if the problem isn't a Shutterfly error or you ask after 60 days
  • No voice or video

Which Should You Choose?

The right pick depends on how many you're ordering, where they're going and how soon.

Choose Mpix if...

  • You're ordering several copies of one design and want the lowest total
  • You want two photos on one ornament
  • You like a ready-made holiday design or a shape like Snowflake or Oval
  • You're shipping within the U.S. and can use Standard shipping
  • You want the order gift-boxed for $10.00

Choose Shutterfly if...

  • You want a larger ornament, up to 3x5 in.
  • You need it fast and want Super Rush, with a guaranteed arrival date in the cart
  • You're shipping to Canada or another country
  • You'd rather upload your own finished design
  • You prefer a brand with a large Trustpilot review base

Want an Ornament That Plays Their Voice? Consider Remento

Neither Mpix nor Shutterfly's metal ornament can hold a voice or video recording. The Remento Ornament puts your photo on a 2.87 in. ceramic ornament with a QR code on the back, so the people in the photo can tell the story behind it in their own voices. Unlimited family and friends can add audio or video recordings, and anyone can listen by scanning the code, with no app needed. It costs $29.99 (one ornament, one-time).

Order a Remento Ornament

Frequently Asked Questions

Mpix vs Shutterfly ornaments: which is cheaper?

Mpix. One Mpix Custom Ornament is $19.99 and one Shutterfly metal ornament is $24.99 at regular price. Mpix drops to $17.50 each when you order two or more with the same design.

Is Mpix better quality than Shutterfly?

For metal photo ornaments, the two are level. Both print in full color on aluminum on both sides: Mpix on a glossy 1/16 in. aluminum sheet, Shutterfly on coated aluminum. Both score 4.5/5 for ornament quality by our ornament rating criteria.

Which ships faster, Mpix or Shutterfly?

It depends on the shipping you pick. Mpix spends 1-2 business days in the lab, then Standard shipping takes 2-7 days and Expedited 1-2 business days. Shutterfly's production plus delivery ranges from 6-10 business days (Basic Economy) to 1-2 business days (Super Rush).

What is the last day to order Mpix or Shutterfly ornaments for Christmas?

For 2026, Mpix lists December 16 for Standard and December 21 for Expedited shipping for delivery by December 25, and says it can't guarantee delivery times. Shutterfly lists December 16 (Economy), December 18 (Expedited), December 19 (Rush, 4 PM PT) and December 21 (Super Rush, 4 PM PT).

Do Mpix and Shutterfly ornaments print on both sides?

Yes. Mpix prints a front and back design on every Custom Ornament. Shutterfly offers two-sided personalization with photos and text, designed for one photo.

Do Mpix and Shutterfly ornaments come ready to gift?

Both come with a red ribbon for hanging. Shutterfly adds a soft protective pouch. Mpix offers boutique gift packaging for $10.00, with one box per order.

Can you return an Mpix or Shutterfly ornament?

Mpix's product page says its ornaments are 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed but doesn't list the terms there. Shutterfly offers a 100% Happiness Guarantee; if the issue isn't a Shutterfly error or you ask more than 60 days after ordering, it may give store credit or charge a 50% return fee, and return shipping isn't refunded.

The Verdict: Mpix vs Shutterfly

Mpix is the better value. It costs $5.00 less per ornament, drops to $17.50 each for matching copies, allows two photos and offers twice as many shapes. That makes it the stronger pick for sets of ornaments shipped within the U.S. Shutterfly is the better choice when size, speed or destination matters most: it offers a 3x5 in. Gift Tag, Super Rush delivery with a guaranteed date, a protective pouch in the box and shipping outside the U.S. On print quality, the two are even. Decide on quantity and deadline, and the right brand becomes clear.

Related Reading

Like what you see? Share with a friend.
An older woman with short gray hair, sitting comfortably on a white couch, smiling warmly while holding a pink book titled 'Claudette's Best Stories' with a black-and-white photo on the cover. The cozy living room features soft lighting and a large window in the background.

Their stories, forever at your fingertips

Remento’s life story books turn a parent or grandparent’s memories of the past into a keepsake book for the future - no writing required.

Explore Remento

Capture priceless family memories today

Join the thousands of families using Remento to preserve family history, all without writing a word.

Get Started Today